Swen Hutter (Foto: David Ausserhofer), Gesine Höltmann (Foto: Martina Sander)09.09.2021
Polarisation and Cohesion in the Corona Crisis: a Look at Civil Society
More polarisation at the same time means less cohesion – this is what the public debate suggests. However, a look at civil society and civic engagement during the Corona crisis shows how strongly these two dynamics are interwoven. Signs that point in one direction or the other should therefore not be interpreted too quickly. A guest contribution by Gesine Höltmann, research assistant at the Centre for Civil Society Research (a joint initiative of the Berlin Social Science, WZB, and the Freie Universität Berlin) and Swen Hutter, Deputy Director of the WZB and Professor of Political Sociology at the Freie Universität Berlin.
Social crises, be they economic, nature-related or of a social nature, always have two facets: Primarily, crises have a destructive, often polarising effect. They destroy livelihoods, consolidate or exacerbate existing inequalities or create a severe loss of confidence in politics and governments. In the midst of these societal states of exception, however, there are always rays of hope, as we have experienced with natural disasters, with grassroots mobilisation in the context of the financial crisis or after the arrival of numerous refugees in Germany in 2015. We see again and again that crises of the most varied kinds can be moments of solidarity, of sticking together and of lived helpfulness.
In contrast to previous crises, however, in the current pandemic there is legitimate concern that contact restrictions and the temporary suspension of public life have not only restricted civil society in the short term, but will also change it in the medium and long term. In the research project “Potentials of Civil Society” (SolZiv), we are therefore investigating the extent and conditions of solidarity behaviour in civil society forms during the Corona pandemic. In this article, we present our first empirical results and discuss what the (de)activation of civil society in the context of the Corona crisis could mean for polarisation and social cohesion.
First of all, it can be said that there was no need to worry about a complete standstill in social and political engagement. Neighbours and volunteers did not let the restrictions on contact prevent them from shopping for others, erecting fences and organizing themselves. Also in the area of political engagement, creative forms of protest quickly emerged – restaurateurs populated the public space with empty chairs, and Fridays for Future called for online protests. At the same time, the lateral thinker movement with its loud opposition to the Corona measures was able to establish itself through classic protests. However, these reports of solidarity and protest should not reassure us straight away. Instead we have to ask ourselves: How sustainable is this engagement? What changes are we already observing for the social capital of society, and is civil society permanently impaired or also enriched in ways that may not yet be visible?
Great need for support
We see signs of increased cohesion in the Corona crisis above all in the activation of individual prosocial action: Around sixty percent of those surveyed offered support outside of their household in the period from March to October 2020. Most of them did shopping for other people, looked after children, or supported them in everyday life. At the beginning of the crisis there were even more offers of support than were actually made use of. First and foremost, however, the own social environment was the focus of the help: The vast majority (82 percent) supported friends and family as well as neighbours (50 percent) – only 15 percent supported people they did not know before the Corona crisis. The “little us” has a primary role to play in overcoming the crisis and in strengthening local cohesion.
The extent to which this willingness to help can strengthen social cohesion also depends on whether the many support offers were able to meet the demand. Our results show that around a quarter of the German population received support from people outside their household, with a third of these support relationships being newly established during the crisis. One in ten stated that they needed more support, and around half of them did not receive any support.
The need in the population is not only strongly structured in a socio-economic way – also the additional crisis burden caused by Corona infections in the household, care obligations and childcare become visible. We also observe that a large social network was beneficial for support during the pandemic. Conversely, the needs of people who are less socially integrated tend to go unnoticed. Also on the “recipient side”, we found that the personal environment was the primary source of support, while neighbours, foreigners and civil society organisations played a more complementary role.
Beyond the spontaneous willingness to help, we should also consider organised civil society: The collective places of engagement are particularly relevant to the community and the preservation of social capital. Together with colleagues at the Institute for Protest and Movement Research (ipb), we therefore also surveyed civil society actors in Germany in the SolZiv project – from football clubs to “Grandmas against the right”. Around 25 percent of the organisations surveyed provided financial and material support for those affected; a further 14 percent have organised specific pandemic-related neighbourhood help. However, these positive findings should not hide the fact that the Corona crisis hit organised civil society hard and led to a severe deactivation: Almost three quarters of the organisations we surveyed stated that the crisis had a negative or very negative impact on their work. An important part of solidarity and helpfulness therefore took place in the informal area, as shown.
We also see this increased informalisation of civic engagement in the Corona crisis in protest actions. At first glance, the Corona protests of the so-called lateral thinkers movement appear to be the opposite pole to solidarity support. Here, there is also a loose and informal organisation that arose with the mobilisation and did not precede it. As Edgar Grande and colleagues show, from June to November 2020 around 20 percent of those surveyed in Germany expressed a great deal of understanding for the protests, while around one in ten people would take part in them themselves. Analogous to the radicalisation of the movement, however, the part of the population that explicitly speaks out against the protests and distances themselves from them has also grown. The protests have therefore also mobilised the public: A majority of society has resolutely opposed these demands.
The discourse on division and cohesion is mostly based on the assumption that more polarisation also means less cohesion. In fact, however, at the same time we are observing highly ambivalent developments in the current crisis: First of all, a prosocial activation can be ascertained, which creates the impression of increased cohesion and expresses a high degree of helpfulness. The good news is that engagement has not come to a standstill. At the same time, organised civil society was hit hard and people without a close-knit social network in particular tended to receive too little support. Furthermore, the pandemic has brought to light anti-social tendencies and have exacerbated existing or created new inequalities that can provide an additional basis for further polarisation.
However, this simultaneity of polarisation and cohesion also creates impetus for social negotiation processes: whether they be about the anti-science and post-factual statements of lateral thinkers or the social grievances, for example in the care sector. In our opinion, the direction in which these negotiations turn in the context of the Corona crisis depends heavily on how sustainable and resilient informal alliances in civil society prove to be.
The article previously appeared in a longer version in the WZB (Berlin Social Science Center) reports. (German only)
- Insights Credit: André BakkerInsightsA guest contribution by Brain City Ambassador Prof. Dr Anabel Ternès von Hattburg, Professor for International Business Administration at the SRH…→
Getting on Board with Digitality
- Insights Foto: "Lucid Dream", Elena Kunau and Mariya YordanovaInsightsARTIFICIAL REALITY – VIRTUAL INTELLIGENCE is the name of an exhibition that can be seen from 8 to 12 September as part of Ars Electronica Garden…→
Interaction via Emotion
- Insights Credit: Peter Himsel/Campus Berlin-Buch GmbHInsightsThe Campus Berlin-Buch in the north of Brain City Berlin has grown to become one of Europe’s largest business and research centres for life sciences.→
A Vibrant Healthcare Network
- Insights Credit: Markus KrutzikInsightsDr. Markus Krutzik, Head of the Joint Lab Integrated Quantum Sensors (IQS), on the "Wissenschaft trifft Wirtschaft" (Science Meets Business") event…→
"I am Fascinated by the Possibilities of Quantum Sensors"
- Insights Foto: ESCP Business School BerlinInsightsWhat to do when distance is suddenly the order of the day? A guest contribution by Dr. René Mauer, Professor of Entrepreneurship und Innovation at…→
Using Whiteboards to Combat Digital Fatigue
- Insights Credit: Alexander Rentsch/HTW BerlinInsightsBrain City Ambassador Prof. Dr. Florian Koch of HTW Berlin brings together science, business and civil society in his research.→
“Increasing Urbanisation also Creates Opportunities”
- Insights Credit: Rudolf GrillborzerInsightsGuest contribution by Brain City Ambassador Dr.-Ing. Onur Günlü, Technische Universität Berlin.→
Exploring the "ultimate limits"
- Insights Credt: Startup Incubator BerlinInsightsThe Startup Incubator Berlin at the Berlin School of Economics and Law is particularly successful in supporting founder teams – as proved by the fact…→
“We Bring Ideas to Market”
- Insights Credit: Mimi Thian on UnsolashInsightsGuest Contribution by Brain City Ambassador Dr. Petyo Budakov, University of Europe for Applied Sciences.→
“Proudly presenting Brain City Berlin in 2020”
- Insights Susanne Plaumann (private)InsightsInterview with Brain City Ambassador Susanne Plaumann M.A., Central women's representative at the Beuth University of Applied Sciences Berlin.→
“Careers are now easier to plan for women scientists”
- Insights Adi Goldstein auf UnsplashInsightsStadtManufaktur Berlin conceptually unites research projects of the TU Berlin under a single roof. The long-term goal of this “open laboratory…→
Science in Dialogue with the City
- Insights Falk WeißInsightsThe knowledge portal “humboldts17” presents current research on the subject of sustainability and welcomes open dialogue with the general public. The…→
17 Goals for the Future
- Insights Foto: Olga Makarova privatInsightsBrain City Ambassador Olga Makarova reflects on being a microbiologist during the pandemic, and the urgent need for microbiology literacy in society.→
Guest Contribution: COVID-19 and microbiology literacy
- Insights HIIGInsightsBrain City-Interview with Prof. Dr. Wolfgang Schulz, Research Director at the Alexander von Humboldt Institute for Internet and Society (HIIG).→
“A sustainable goal of our work is to make clear what the technology can actually do”
- Insights HTW BerlinInsightsAn interview with Brain City Ambassador Prof. Dr. Kai Reinhardt. On October 28, he will be speaking at the second SpreeTalk at HTW University of…→
“The pandemic has been a catalyst for digitalization”
- Insights dentalXr.aiInsightsdentalXrai is the first dental start-up to be spun off the Charité. It was launched via the accelerator of the Berlin Institute of Health (BIH). We…→
Artificial intelligence in the fight against tooth decay
- Insights Anna Raysyan (private)InsightsBrain City Ambassador Anna Raysyan has been living in Berlin for 3,5 years now. She is a PhD student at the Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und…→
Guest Contribution: “Berlin likes the bold!”
- Insights ©Berlin Partner für Wirtschaft und TechnologieInsightsMany top-class researchers and scientists are being attracted to Brain City Berlin every year. The Dual Career Network Berlin helps partners of…→
Dual Career Network Berlin: getting a good start in Berlin
- Insights ©Matthias PicketInsightsDr. Anne Schreiter, Managing Director of the German Scholars Organization (GSO), reveals in the Brain City interview what alternative career…→
"Science is not just about research"
- Insights © Pocky Lee on UnsplashInsightsMatches in front of empty stadiums, virtual marathons, and many postponed events. Brain City Ambassador Professor Gabriele Mielke is tracking the…→
"Now is the time for innovators"
- Insights © AW Creative on UnsplashInsightsJuggling a degree course or teaching with the extra burden of the care of children or other family members is not an easy task. Both students and…→
From “Zoo School” to “Maternity Protection”: family-friendly universities
- Insights © HTW Berlin / Nikolas FahlbuschInsightsTeaching is currently only taking place online. Guest author Dr Dorothee Haffner, professor for Museology at HTW Berlin - University of Applied…→
Guest contribution: "Online teaching is more engaging than I thought"
- Insights Franziska SattlerInsightsIn the interview: Brain City ambassador Franziska Sattler on her series of events "Kaffeeklatsch mit Wissenschaft" (Talking Science over Coffee) at…→
"Science needs the trust of society"
- Insights Fotocredit: Ortner & Ortner / SiemensInsightsSiemensstadt 2.0 is a place of the future. The Berlin Senate has approved 9.9 million euros for the first research project "Electrical Drive…→
Siemensstadt 2.0: Research and industry closely linked
- Insights ©Credit Silke Oßwald/FMPInsightsBrain City interview: Professor Dr. Volker Haucke, Director at the Leibniz-Forschungsinstitut für Molekulare Pharmakologie (FMP) and Professor of…→
In the balancing act between detail and overall concept
- Insights © hj barraza/UnsplashInsightsOur guest author Dr Barbara Schäuble is Professor for Diversity-Conscious Approaches in the Theory and Practice of Social Work at ASH Berlin and a…→
Guest contribution: A sudden change of course - classes moved online
- Insights ©DexLeChemInsightsLaunching a start-up while at university? Sonja Jost's success shows the way. Together with three fellow students, she founded DexLeChem after…→
"Bringing new knowledge to the market is very important to us"
- Insights ©Ivar Veermäe / Centre for EntrepreneurshipInsightsBrain City Berlin is the German capital of start-ups. Many young companies have successfully been founded through Berlin and Brandenburg based…→
"Society in particular benefits from high-tech start-ups" - university survey enters its third round
- Insights ©BIH|Thomas RafalzykInsightsAt the Berlin Institute of Health (BIH) the main focus is on "translational research" - the transfer of findings from the research lab into clinical…→
“There are now many great female scientists, achieving great things”
- Insights ©fotografixx - istockphoto.comInsightsIn the digital age learning behaviour changes profoundly. It is student-centered and technology rich. As a member of the Erasmus+ funded project…→
Exploring the future of learning
- Insights © Brain City BerlinInsightsResearch results quickly and easily accessible online: The Open Access movement is campaigning for a paradigm shift in the field of publications and…→
Open Access: free knowledge for everyone
- Insights ©ESCP EUROPEInsights29.10.2019 | Professor Andreas Kaplan is a Brain City Berlin ambassador and Rector of ESCP Europe Business School Berlin. The economist's research is…→
"We have to be able to take everyone on the journey."
- Insights Gudrun Piechotta-HenzeInsightsIn time for the 2020/21 winter semester, ASH, the Alice Salomon University of Applied Sciences Berlin, is launching the first bachelor's degree to…→
"We have to completely rethink nursing!" | 27.09.2019
- Insights ©Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin/Matthias HeydeInsightsThe courses offered by the HUWISU Summer University are varied and exciting, the target group is international: students from abroad who come to…→
When Berlin becomes one large seminar room ... | 15.08.2019
- Insights [Translate to English:]InsightsThe literary scholar Dr. Betiel Wasihun was traveling for science. After stops in Heidelberg, Yale, and Oxford, it brought her to Berlin two years…→
“Berlin is a perfect location. Especially if you don’t want to pursue just a single avenue of scientific work.” | 12.08.2019
- Insights [Translate to English:] Berlin University Alliance/Matthias HeydeInsightsTogether we are stronger. And also more successful. As the "Berlin University Alliance," the Technische Universität Berlin, the Freie Universität…→
Congratulations: The “Berlin University Alliance“ receives funding of the Excellence Strategy |19.07.2019
- Insights [Translate to English:] David Ausserhofer/IGBInsightsBerlin is one of the most water-rich cities in Germany. But climate change does not stop at the Havel, Spree or Wannsee either. Dr. Michael Hupfer is…→
"We're trying to take a look into the future." | 04.07.2019
- Insights [Translate to English:] Helena Lopes / UnsplashInsightsSend a digital lollipop or delicate fragrance notes via email or let the wind virtually blow against your face - research makes it possible. Learn…→
Experiencing the digital world with all senses | 18.06.2019
- Insights [Translate to English:] HZB/M. SetzpfandtInsightsIn these times of fake news and pseudo-scientific publications, many people find it difficult to distinguish legitimate from dubious content. Only 54%…→
"Science needs to make us curious" | 11.06.2019
- Insights [Translate to English:] Tim LandgrafInsightsBrain City Berlin is considered one of the leading locations in Germany working on artificial intelligence. About 30% of all German AI companies are…→
Fish, bees, and self-driving cars | 07.06.2019
- Insights [Translate to English:]InsightsScience and cultural heritage, freely accessible to everyone at any time on the Internet: The Open Access movement is promoting a paradigm shift in…→
Knowledge for All - Open Access in Berlin | 28.03.2019
- Insights [Translate to English:] Thomas Rosenthal - Museum für Naturkunde BerlinInsights660 million euros in 10 years: The Natural History Museum Berlin - Museum für Naturkunde Berlin receives financial support for the further development…→
Future of the Museum für Naturkunde Berlin | 14.01.2019
- Insights [Translate to English:]InsightsSpace exploration is experiencing a revolution thanks to commercialization by such companies as Elon Musk's SpaceX. But did you know that more facets…→
From Berlin to the moon: the space industry is booming in Berlin | 03.09.2018